Can you cite AI in classwork? Should you?


I’ve tried to wrap my brain around the relationship that AI assistants like ChatGPT have with the facts, with their sources, with reality.

Here’s the best analogy I can come up with. (Note that I’m from Indiana, a very agriculture-based state, so if this analogy seems crude, my apologies … I’m just speaking the language of my people. 😂) 

AI assistants produce information kind of like a meat grinder produces sausage.

At the top of a meat grinder, you can add all sorts of meat … all different parts of the animal … and it all goes into the meat grinder.

What comes out? Hotdogs. Sausages. Ground beef and sausage and … other things.

What would happen if someone questioned the butcher later and asked, “What is this little part I see here?”

Likely answer: the butcher would shrug and say, “I’m not exactly sure. It’s just sausage now.”

The AI models that power AI assistants like ChatGPT learn from a variety of sources. For example, some more reputable (published books and academic journals) … some less reputable (personal blogs and popular Reddit posts).

AI models don’t learn in a linear fashion like we’d prefer — with direct links back to everything it produces. 

Instead, they’re more like our own brains. (Because their architecture is inspired by the human brain.) We file away lots of things in our memory and often say, “I can’t remember exactly where I heard this, but …”.

We wouldn’t cite “I can’t remember exactly where I heard this” from a friends, family or colleagues. Unless we can see the information in context, there will be doubt.





Source link

  • Related Posts

    President Trump and the Department of Education

    In a significant policy shift, President Trump has initiated plans to dismantle the U.S. Department of Education (ED). This plan aims to decentralize educational control to individual states. The move…

    Renewing your Professional Educator Certification – Pennsylvania

    What you need: You can renew in a few ways: earning six-semester credits of collegiate study, six CPE credits of PDE (Pennsylvania Department of Education)-approved continuing professional education courses, or…

    You Missed

    President Trump and the Department of Education

    President Trump and the Department of Education

    Renewing your Professional Educator Certification – Pennsylvania

    Renewing your Professional Educator Certification – Pennsylvania

    Incorporating Black History Month in Your Classroom: Resources Included!

    Incorporating Black History Month in Your Classroom: Resources Included!

    Renewing your Standard Teaching Certificate – New York

    Renewing your Standard Teaching Certificate – New York

    How to Practice Equitable Empathy: What White Faculty Should–and Shouldn’t–Do – Faculty Focus

    How to Practice Equitable Empathy: What White Faculty Should–and Shouldn’t–Do – Faculty Focus

    National School Counseling Week 2025

    National School Counseling Week 2025